Lying about past heroics is beginning to seem like a common occurrence among some of America's male, white, rich, famous and powerful.
VA Secretary Robert McDonald apologizes for misstating military recordSecretary of Veterans Affairs lied about being in a "special operations" division during a recent TV interview
Robert McDonald, the secretary of veterans affairs, misrepresented his military record in a recent TV appearance, falsely stating that he was in an elite special operations division.
McDonald, a West Point grad who served with the 82nd Airborne Division during the late 1970s, has issued an apology for the misstatement, reported the Huffington Post’s David Wood.
There was no suggestion in Wood’s story of any pattern of misstatements by McDonald. The comment in question came while McDonald was being filmed by a CBS News crew as he toured Los Angeles during a count of homeless veterans, one of whom told McDonald he had served in special ops. McDonald replied: “Special forces? What years? I was in special forces.” The segment aired Jan. 30.
Bill O'Reilly Caught Lying About Being in a "War Zone"
Big Media Has Been Very Forgiving of Bill O'Reilly Past 'Macho' Transgressions
Bill O'Reilly Settle's Sexual Harassment Suit With Produce - Pays Millions
O'Reilly Lied About CBS Reporters Hiding In The Hotel —
Says Former CBS Reporter Eric Engberg
Bill O’Reilly’s Masculinity Problem: Why Anchormen Make Up Lies and Pretend They Are Heroes
By Rhonda Garelick
Close on the heels of the Brian Williams saga comes today’s allegation that Fox News’s Bill O’Reilly may also have misled the public, claiming to have risked life and limb reporting from the Falkland Islands during the war there, when in fact he’d been comfortably stationed 1,200 miles away in Buenos Aires—and after the war’s end. Yet as the articles about O’Reilly multiply, as in the case of Williams, the most important ramification of these stories is being entirely overlooked. Let’s step back and consider the kind of stories these men recounted and what these anecdotes reveal about journalism and about us, the audience.
Williams and O’Reilly told war stories. Williams spoke of accompanying elite military troops, getting shot down by enemy fire, and helping land a helicopter in dangerous territory. He even claimed to have received an imposing combat knife, a ‘throat cutter,’ from a member of Seal Team Six, the unit that killed Osama Bin Laden—which he jokingly professes to use now to intimidate colleagues at NBC meetings.
War stories are guarantors of masculinity and power. By telling them—true or embellished—Williams and O’Reilly were attempting to ally themselves with those attributes, to put themselves in league with heroes. Williams’ story even includes flashing a deadly military weapon—that ‘throat cutter’—at studio meetings, transforming his tame, workaday world (metaphorically) into a battle zone.
Why did they do this? What would lead an anchorman to burnish his reputation with such stories? What have über-masculine war heroes to do with anchormen? Plenty.
An “anchorman” is not just a journalist. He is, as the word implies, something weighty, grounding, central, and yes faintly military, or more precisely, naval. Those qualities also connote masculinity—witness the fact that “anchorwoman” is not a word we often use. When a woman exercises this profession, we usually omit the suffix, and say that Katie Couric and Diane Sawyer are simply “anchors.” This is because “anchorwoman” sounds odd to our ears, even oxymoronic. Femininity is traditionally understood as lightness to masculine stability, the ballerina leaping into her male partner’s secure arms. Women’s presence, alas, does not seem to ‘anchor.’
NBC's Brian Williams: There Are Some Other Tall Tales He Might Want to Apologize For
|Not getting shot down in Iraq is just the beginning of things Brian |
Williams needs to correct.
NBC Nightly News anchor Brian Williams has apologized for falsely claiming (NBC, 1/30/15) that "during the invasion of Iraq…the helicopter we were traveling in was forced down after being hit by an RPG."
"I made a mistake in recalling the events of 12 years ago," he told his audience on February 4 (Stars & Stripes, 2/4/15). "I don't know what screwed up in my mind that caused me to conflate one aircraft with another."
Now that he's cleared that up, there are some other tall tales that Williams might want to take back. Take his recounting of the aftermath of Hurricane Katrina in New Orleans (Dateline NBC, 8/22/10; Extra!, 10/10):
You know, I’ve been around a lot of guns and a lot of dead bodies, and a lot of people shooting at people to make dead bodies. But you put them all together and you put it in the United States of America, and boy, it gets your attention….As long as he's in a confessional mood, Williams might as well admit that he didn't see "a lot of people shooting at people to make dead bodies," nor would people have killed him for his car if he hadn't been surrounded by feds–none of which appeared in his original reporting. The New York Times ( 9/29/05 ) cited a state medical officials' tally that "six or seven deaths appear to have been the result of homicides" in the wake of the storm. As the New Orleans Times Picayune (9/26/05) put it in a Pulitzer Prize-winning story a month after Katrina:
It was clear already there weren’t going to be enough cops…. Everywhere we went, every satellite shot, every camera shot, we were at the height of the violence and the looting and the—all the reports of gunplay downtown. Well, who's bathed in the only lights in town? It was us….
We had to ask Federal Protection Service guys with automatic weapons to just form a ring and watch our backs while we were doing Dateline NBC one night…. State troopers had to cover us by aiming at the men in the street just to tell them, "Don't think of doing a smash and grab and killing this guy for the car."
As the fog of warlike conditions in Hurricane Katrina's aftermath has cleared, the vast majority of reported atrocities committed by evacuees have turned out to be false, or at least unsupported by any evidence, according to key military, law enforcement, medical and civilian officials in positions to know…. Four weeks after the storm, few of the widely reported atrocities have been backed with evidence. The piles of bodies never materialized, and soldiers, police officers and rescue personnel on the front lines say that although anarchy reigned at times and people suffered unimaginable indignities, most of the worst crimes reported at the time never happened.Or perhaps Williams would like to withdraw his remark (9/27/13; FAIR Action Alert, 9/30/13) that Iran was "suddenly claiming they don't want nuclear weapons"–and acknowledge that Iranian President Mahmoud Ahmadinejad (NBC Nightly News, 7/28/08) had told him personally in an interview five years earlier: "We are not working to manufacture a bomb. We don't believe in a nuclear bomb." And that that was a repetition of what Ahmadinejad (NBC Nightly News, 9/19/06) had told him two years before that: "We have said on numerous occasions that our activities are for peaceful purposes…. We are against the atomic bomb."
|Brian Williams reporting from a non-imaginary New Orleans.|
And despite what Williams claimed on March 8, 2005 (Extra!, 6/05), the invasion did not actually spark a wave of democratization in the Middle East that made "even the harshest critics of President Bush…admit maybe he's right about freedom’s march around the globe." Nor did George W. Bush provide "an example of presidential leadership that will be taught in American schools for generations to come."
He might want to clear that up.